She says by the time 4 a.m. rolled around, the severe part of the weather calmed enough for her to look outside. That’s when she saw flood waters surrounding her home on Estes Road, so she called 911.

In 1994, Tatrow was the ringleader in the kidnapping, torture, and murder of Zammit and John Allen Harry. Dunaway reports that Tatrow and his co-defendants kidnapped the victims and tied them up in ...